José Mota — Web engineer & architect

To show or not to show [registered user only actions]

April 20th, 2010

Last week I struggled with a design decision that really caught my attention. Consider this:

  • You have a user driven app on the web.
  • You also provide some actions for guests.

What you would do? Either:

  1. Don’t show the user only actions? (my opinion: this one reduces clutter on your interface).
  2. Or do show them and when the user clicks the links/buttons, the user gets a login redirected page for every new click?

My pick would be number 1. Why?

I’d rather have a welcome page that showed you what to use in case you signed up. Actions such as creating a new item on a product list and message sending that apparently require a sign up are confusing for a guest. Besides, clicking on such an action and redirecting you to a login page several times is not that much of an engaging experience.

Feel free to add up on this thought.

No one shared an insight yet.

Leave a comment!